Securities Attorney for Going Public Transactions

Securities Lawyer Blog

knowledge itself is power

California Court of Appeal Rules That Partial Sale of Business Can Bind Seller-Owner to a Noncompetition Agreement

In a landmark decision, the California Court of Appeal in Samuelian v. Life Generations Healthcare, LLC, — Cal. App. 5th —, 2024 WL 3878448 (Cal. App. Aug. 20, 2024), addressed two critical questions regarding noncompetition agreements in the context of the partial sale of a business. The court held that:

  1. A partial sale of an ownership interest may support a noncompetition agreement under the "rule of reason," even though the statutory exception under Business & Professions Code Section 16601 requires the sale of an entire business interest for a noncompete to be enforceable.

  2. An LLC member’s fiduciary obligations, if contractually imposed, may allow for a noncompete during the period of membership.

In this case, two LLC members sold part of their interest while retaining a minority stake with fiduciary obligations and voting rights. The operating agreement included a noncompetition clause for members, which became the focal point of the dispute. The court ruled that such noncompetition agreements, particularly in partial sales, must be assessed for reasonableness, weighing their competitive benefits against any potential harm to competition.

This decision highlights the importance for businesses to carefully structure noncompetition agreements and consult legal counsel to ensure compliance with California law, especially following partial sales of business interests.

Gayatri Gupta