Securities Attorney for Going Public Transactions

Securities Lawyer Blog

knowledge itself is power

SEC's Approach to Crypto Regulation: Navigating Enforcement-Based Guidance in a Growing Industry

The rapid expansion of cryptocurrency, blockchain, and Web3 has placed them squarely in the SEC’s regulatory sights, yet the agency's approach largely revolves around enforcement rather than clear rule-making. This enforcement-focused method has led the industry to adopt a three-fold strategy: ignoring regulation, challenging it, and in some cases, negotiating compliance frameworks, as demonstrated by the high-profile Ripple and BlockFi cases. This blog explores the impact of this strategy, highlighting how enforcement-based guidance has created uncertainty and fueled international expansion among cryptocurrency firms.

Enforcement Actions in Place of Clear Regulations

Since the SEC’s DAO report in 2017, the agency has primarily enforced regulations on cryptocurrency entities, with high-profile cases like Ripple exemplifying the "fight it" mantra. Ripple’s argument hinges on fair notice, questioning how participants can follow rules that lack clarity or consistent enforcement. This defense challenges the SEC’s reliance on litigation to establish guidance and has rallied the crypto community in support.

Using Enforcement to Forge a Path: The BlockFi Case

In 2022, BlockFi reached a settlement with the SEC, paying $100 million in fines while securing a framework for registering its crypto lending product. This unusual outcome, where the SEC provided a compliance path forward, underscores that enforcement can sometimes act as an alternative to regulatory clarity—if firms have the resources to negotiate.

Consequences of an Enforcement-Driven Framework

The SEC’s strategy creates obstacles for smaller players who lack the resources for prolonged legal battles or costly settlements, often driving innovation offshore or into legal gray areas. The approach has also impacted areas beyond cryptocurrency, such as SPACs, unlicensed broker-dealers, and insider trading, with ongoing legal actions and evolving judicial rulings.

The Future of Regulation by Enforcement

As the crypto industry continues to expand, the SEC’s reliance on enforcement may hinder its own goals of investor protection and market stability. With an evolving crypto landscape, clear, predictable regulations are essential to protect both the industry and investor interests, ensuring compliance is accessible to all market participants.

Gayatri Gupta