The 211 Rules And Shell Companies
The panic among OTC Markets shell companies is likely related to the upcoming expiration of the 18-month period granted by the 15c2-11 rules for shell companies to retain eligibility. These rules, which came into effect on September 28, 2021, provide a piggyback exception allowing broker-dealers to publish quotations for shell companies for a limited period of 18 months. This exception enables shell companies to complete a reverse merger with an operating business or begin operations themselves within the specified timeframe.
For companies that were shell companies on September 28, 2021, and still fall into the shell status, the 18-month period will expire on March 28, 2023. The panic is likely driven by the urgency for these companies to take appropriate actions within the given timeframe to maintain their eligibility under the 15c2-11 rules.
It's important for OTC Markets shell companies to carefully assess their situation, evaluate strategic options, and consider taking necessary steps to meet the regulatory requirements within the specified timeframe. This may involve pursuing a reverse merger, implementing a business plan to commence operations, or exploring other avenues that align with regulatory expectations. Companies facing this deadline should consult legal and financial professionals for guidance tailored to their specific circumstances.
What is a Shell Company?
The definition of a shell company, as per Rule 15c2-11, aligns with Securities Act Rules 405 and 144 and Exchange Act Rule 12b-2. It includes an issuer, excluding business combination-related shell companies and asset-backed issuers, that has no or nominal operations and either no or nominal assets, or assets consisting solely of cash or cash equivalents, or assets consisting of any amount of cash and cash equivalents and nominal other assets. Notably, startups or companies with limited operating history are not automatically deemed shells; a "reasonable basis" must be established for this determination based on factors such as public filings, financial statements, and business descriptions.
As the 18-month deadline approaches for companies that were shell companies on September 28, 2021, OTC Markets has provided FAQs for shell companies on its 15c2-11 resource center page. OTC Markets has also assigned a surveillance team to review shell status, and a company may be identified as a shell if it self-identifies as such in SEC periodic reports or reports filed with OTC Markets through the alternative disclosure system.
It's important to distinguish this process from the ongoing "shell risk" designation that OTC Markets may periodically apply to companies. The shell risk flag is determined at OTC Markets' discretion based on an evaluation of various metrics such as asset composition, operational expenditures, and income-related factors. If a company receives a shell risk flag, it has the opportunity to provide evidence, including changes in financial condition reflected in publicly reported financial statements, to request the removal of the flag.
What will Happen to a Shell Company That Has Remained a Shell for 18 Months?
If a company qualifies as a shell company and remains in that status for 18 months, it will lose piggyback eligibility under Rule 15c2-11. However, it won't lose the unsolicited quotation exception. If the company also fails to maintain current information as mandated by Rule 15c2-11, it will be shifted to the Expert Market on OTC Markets.
The move to the Expert Market means the company's securities will be quoted based on unsolicited customer orders and broker-dealer requests, but the absence of piggyback eligibility indicates a loss of efficiency in the quoting process. It's important for companies in this situation to diligently work towards regaining or maintaining compliance with Rule 15c2-11 to ensure optimal market access.
Piggyback Exception
Rule 15c2-11 is a crucial regulation governing when a broker-dealer can initiate or continue to quote a security. The rule mandates that there must be current public information about a company to facilitate a broker-dealer's information review, ensuring accuracy and reliability.
The piggyback exception is an important aspect of Rule 15c2-11, allowing a broker-dealer to rely on an information review completed by entities like OTC Markets or another broker-dealer. To qualify for this exception, certain conditions must be met, including the requirement for current and publicly available information, the presence of at least a one-way priced quotation from another broker-dealer, and a limitation on the number of consecutive days without a quotation.
Moreover, the rule sets specific criteria, such as the absence of an SEC trading suspension within the prior 60 calendar days and a restriction on shell companies that have been in that status for 18 months. If a company has been a shell for 18 months, it loses eligibility for the piggyback exception, impacting its ability to have its security quoted by a broker-dealer. The rule also includes a conditional 15-day grace period to continue quotations when current information becomes temporarily unavailable.
Unsolicited Quotation Exception
The unsolicited quotation exception provides an alternative for broker-dealers to quote a security, allowing for certain scenarios where a customer requests a quote for a security, and the broker-dealer provides the quote in response to that specific request. This exception is distinct from the piggyback exception, and its application is not affected by a company's status as a shell.
When a company loses piggyback eligibility due to being a shell for 18 months, it can still rely on the unsolicited quotation exception. This exception allows the company's security to be quoted by broker-dealers upon customer request, even if the piggyback exception is no longer available.
Despite losing piggyback eligibility, the company's quotation will still be visible on its OTC Markets quotation page. This ensures continued transparency and access to information for the public, even if the company no longer qualifies for the piggyback exception.
Warning! This security is eligible for Unsolicited Quotes Only
The cautionary messages and restrictions imposed on a security's quotation status highlight the challenges and risks associated with trading in stocks of shell companies, especially those subject to the restrictions of Rule 15c2-11. The distinction between proprietary broker-dealer quotations and unsolicited customer orders is crucial in understanding the limitations on market making and trading activities for these securities. The prevalence of trading on an unsolicited basis in the OTC Markets underscores the unique dynamics of these markets, where retail investors often drive activity based on their individual decisions rather than broker recommendations.
The regulatory framework, including the Penny Stock Act and Regulation Best Interest, contributes to the cautious approach taken by broker-dealers when dealing with penny stocks and low-priced, high-risk securities. The focus on risk disclosure and compliance obligations reflects the regulatory intent to protect investors from the inherent risks associated with these types of securities.
Overall, the evolving landscape of OTC Markets, combined with regulatory scrutiny and investor caution, underscores the need for transparency, due diligence, and risk awareness in the trading of such securities. Investors and market participants should carefully consider the specific characteristics and regulatory implications of these securities, recognizing the potential challenges and opportunities they present.
When Will Shell Company Status Be Determined?
The upcoming review of shell company status on March 28, 2023, marks a significant milestone for OTC Markets-listed companies that may be subject to the 18-month rule under Rule 15c2-11. Companies in this category should proactively engage with OTC Markets, providing comprehensive information that supports their argument against being classified as a shell company. This outreach process is essential for maintaining eligibility and avoiding potential disruptions in market access.
The emphasis on early and thorough communication with OTC Markets underscores the importance of companies taking a proactive approach to compliance and demonstrating their operational status. Providing OTC Markets with a detailed discussion about the company's development stage, revenue status, and other pertinent factors will contribute to a more informed decision on shell company classification.
Waiting until the last minute is not advisable, given the time constraints involved in the review process. Companies should act promptly to present their case and address any concerns raised by OTC Markets. This proactive engagement aligns with broader compliance best practices and helps companies navigate regulatory requirements effectively.
What Can a Shell Company do Today – and What it Should Not Do
Companies facing potential shell status under Rule 15c2-11 have several options to consider:
Maintain Current Strategy: Companies can continue with their current strategy, looking for an appropriate business combination target. When such a transaction is closed, the company can then follow the process to retain piggyback eligibility. It's important to note that merely announcing or signing definitive documents for a transaction does not impact shell status; the transaction must be completed.
Expedite Pending Transactions: If a shell company has a pending transaction, expediting the closing process before the March 28 deadline could be an option. This approach also allows for timely filing and review by OTC Markets.
Begin Organic Operations: A shell company contemplating organic operations can initiate these activities immediately. However, the operations must be genuine, and information about the new activities must be provided to OTC Markets with sufficient lead time before the March 28 deadline.
Caution on Placeholder Operations: If a shell company intends to establish temporary placeholder operations to avoid shell status, full disclosure of this intention is crucial. Failure to disclose such intentions could constitute securities fraud. Companies must be transparent about their plans, avoiding misleading statements or omissions that could be deemed fraudulent.
The cautionary note about fully disclosing intentions is particularly important, drawing parallels to historical instances of shell creation without adequate disclosure, leading to enforcement actions and legal consequences. Companies must adhere to securities laws, including Exchange Act Rule 10b-5, which prohibits fraudulent acts, untrue statements, or omissions of material facts in connection with the purchase or sale of securities.
The emphasis on transparent and accurate disclosure aligns with regulatory standards and helps companies navigate these complexities while maintaining compliance with securities laws.
What Can a Company Do to Re-Obtain Piggyback Eligibility?
If a shell company loses piggyback eligibility, it must undergo a new 15c2-11 review by either a broker-dealer or OTC Markets under the initial quotation standards when it ceases to be a shell company. Details on this process can be found in the blog links provided in the opening paragraph. OTC Markets conducts a 211 current information review only for companies applying to the OTCQB or OTCQX tiers of trading. With the increasing disclosure requirements in today's regulatory environment, a target company should ideally meet the criteria for trading on the OTCQB or OTCQX tiers, including obtaining audited financial statements, when considering going public via reverse merger with a public shell company that trades on the Pink Open Market.
Refresher on Current Information Requirements
Rule 15c2-11 aims to ensure adequate current information is available when a security enters the marketplace. Exchange Act Rule 15c2-11 outlines specific information required for maintaining a quotation, including a prospectus under the Securities Act of 1933 (such as a Form S-1), a qualified Regulation A offering circular, the company’s most recent annual and quarterly reports, information published pursuant to Rule 12g3-2(b) for foreign issuers, or specified information similar to those listed.
The 211 rules require current publicly available information to be timely filed or filed within 180 calendar days from a specified date, depending on the company's category. For SEC reporting issuers, the 180-day period begins on the date the reporting period ends. An alternative reporting (catch-all) company must ensure that current information is dated within 12 months of the quotation's publication, with a balance sheet less than 16 months old.
The rule allows a 15-day conditional grace period when current public information is no longer available within the 180-day specified period. Three conditions must be met for the grace period: a public determination by OTC Markets or FINRA that current public information is no longer available, all other conditions for reliance on the piggyback exception must be effective, and the grace period ends on the earliest of the company making current information available or the 14th calendar day after the public determination.
The chart provided in the text summarizes the time frames for which 15c2-11 information must be current and publicly available, timely filed, or filed within 180 calendar days from the specified period.
Category of Company | 15c2-11 Current Information |
---|---|
Exchange Act reporting company | Filed within 180 days following end of a reporting period. |
Regulation A reporting company | Filed within 120 days of fiscal year-end and 90 days of semi-annual period end. |
Regulation Crowdfunding filer | Filed within 120 days of fiscal year-end. |
Foreign Private Issuer | Since first day of most recent completed fiscal year, has filed information required to be filed by the laws of home country or principal exchange traded on. |
Catch-all company | Current and publicly available annually, except the most recent balance sheet must be dated less than 16 months before submission of a quote and profit and loss and retained earnings statements for the 12 months preceding the date of the balance sheet. Note that compliance with the requirement to include financial information for the 2 preceding years does not take effect until 2 years after the effective date (i.e., approximately 2 years and 2 months). A catch-all company would still need to provide all other current information set forth in the rule, to qualify for the piggyback exception, beginning on the compliance date. |
If a company fails to meet the current information requirements, it will be moved to the Expert Market. In the Expert Market, quotations are restricted from public viewing, and only broker-dealers and professional or sophisticated investors are allowed to view quotations in Expert Market securities. Despite these viewing restrictions, the Expert Market does not impose limitations on who can trade the securities. Rule 15c2-11 governs a broker’s ability to submit, publish, or distribute quotations (bids and offers) in OTC securities, and it doesn't regulate the underlying transactions or the ability of an investor to buy or sell a security.
While a company in the Expert Market will still have a quote page on the OTC Markets website, the quotes will not be visible to the public. The quote page will display two black diamonds and carry a message indicating the Expert Market status.
Warning! This security is traded on the Expert Market
The Expert MarketSM is designed to meet the pricing needs of broker-dealers and ensure investor best execution. In Expert Market securities, quotations are restricted from public viewing. OTC Markets Group has the authority to designate securities for quoting on the Expert Market in situations where it cannot confirm that the company is making current information publicly available under SEC Rule 15c2-11, or when the security is subject to other restrictions preventing public quoting. Additional information about the Expert Market can be found here.